The Charter, Section 12: Cruel and Unusual Treatment or Punishment

Question:Would a breach of the right to be free from cruel and unusual punishment cause a trial delay or evidence exclusion in Ontario?

Answer:In Ontario, a breach of an accused person’s Charter right against cruel and unusual punishment (for example, where the conduct amounts to cruel or degrading treatment or a disproportionate punishment) can sometimes lead a judge to order a stay of proceedings or exclude evidence under the Charter remedies framework, depending on how serious the breach was and how it affected the fairness of the trial.   The timing also matters: courts may pause proceedings to hear a voir dire (evidence challenge) or decide on remedies, which can create delay, but it is not automatic for every complaint.   For guidance on whether your situation supports exclusion of evidence or other remedies, DefendCharges.Lawyer can review the facts with a lawyer and explain practical next steps; call (647) 977-5997.

Add this website to Google Preferred Sources

Is it possible to have a charge stayed or evidence excluded from a trial due to a breach on an accused's right not to be treated with cruel and unusual treatment or punishment?

Yes, it is possible for a charge to be stayed or evidence excluded from a trial if the accused's rights have been violated in a manner that constitutes cruel and unusual treatment or punishment.

Note: Please contact DefendCharges.Lawyer by phone at: (647) 977-5997 to discuss any specific questions that you may have.

The Charter of Rights and Freedoms is a cornerstone of Canadian law, and it guarantees all Canadians certain fundamental rights and freedoms.  One of the most important rights is the protection of accused persons from cruel and unusual treatment or punishment.  Under the Charter, accused persons have the right to be treated with dignity and respect.  This means that they cannot be subjected to any form of physical or psychological abuse, or to any form of punishment that is considered to be cruel or unusual.  This includes torture, degrading or inhuman treatment, or any form of punishment that is disproportionate to the crime committed. The Charter also guarantees accused persons the right to a fair trial.  This means that they must be provided with a fair and impartial hearing, and that they must be allowed to present their case in a court of law.  They must also be given access to legal representation, and they must be allowed to challenge any evidence or testimony presented against them.  The Charter also guarantees accused persons the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty.  This means that they cannot be punished or treated as if they are guilty until and unless they are found guilty in a court of law.  Finally, the Charterguarantees accused persons the right to be free from arbitrary detention or imprisonment.  This means that they cannot be held in custody without being charged with a crime, and that they cannot be held for an unreasonable length of time without being brought to trial.

The Law

As per The Constitution Act, 1982, Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), 1982, Chapter 11, a constitutional right to the right not to be subjected to any cruel and unusual treatment or punishment is mandated within section 12 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms which reads:

Summary Comment

The Charter is an important document that protects the rights of accused persons. It ensures that they are treated with dignity and respect, and that they are given a fair trial. It also ensures that they are not subjected to any form of cruel and unusual treatment or punishment. Our experienced criminal lawyers can review your case to determine whether you have been improperly or unnecessarily subjected to any cruel or unusual punishment and explain your legal options.